Tuesday, January 23, 2007
"Hounddog" controversy
Having received a nomination this month at the Sundance Film Festival, a controversy is brewing regarding 12-year old Dakota Fanning's gritty role as a rape victim in "Hounddog," a drama about a troubled young girl (Fanning) finding a safe haven in the music and movement of Elvis Presley.

Last night I watched an interview clip of Dakota Fanning on Fox News. During this interview, she said, ""It's a wonderful film, and I'm really proud to be in it. I can't wait for people to see it." She also stated that she did not find the sexual content of "Hounddog" upsetting.

I'm curious, what are your thoughts on this nominated film? Do you feel her parents should have allowed her to take on such a role at her young age? Would you go see such a movie?

Here are some links to articles I've found on-line:

Dakota Fanning Tackles Sex Abuse in Controversial Role

Dakota Fanning: Some kid

All shook up over Dakota's 'Hounddog'


Labels: ,

6:30 AM
11 comments


11 Comments:
At 5:01 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

OOHHH.....watched this one yesterday...I would have not have let Madison do it...I know its acting...but she would have had nightmares from it.....and it would have killed me to have watched it happen without attacking the guy. I mean I am the mom and I would have gone into mom mode.....I'll come back later to read your other responses....interesting

 
At 6:53 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I haven't seen it. I did see an interview last night on Fox News between someone who did see it and someone who didn't. The person who saw it said it wasn't that bad. She wasn't naked, she wasn't touched and everything was done in the shadows. It was the "appearance" of rape. The person who didn't see it said he wanted to see what was on the cutting room floor that didn't make in the movie after all the controversy came out. As a parent, I don't care how "fake" it was. I wouldn't let my child do it. Just my opinion. I hope someone did look into it and I hope it really was put together in editing. If that were the case, then it really was the parents decision. If there was even the smallest amount of touching involved, then it was wrong on any level.

 
At 7:00 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

They would have had to be REALLY Careful in not only the editing, but also the original taping to avoid potential lawsuits, etc. so I think that the possibility of truly inappropriate touching, etc. is minimal. BUT. I wouldn't let my child do it. I don't think that I could personally watch that being done to my child, no matter how much I told myself it was fake. Dakota Fanning is a professional actress, no matter how young, so she has a totally different childhood than I am accustomed to. But she is STILL just a child. There are thousands of possibilities for her later on in life, to do such a role.

 
At 8:40 AM, Anonymous otto said...

As people begin to actually see this movie, those who chose to condemn the makers of Hounddog before seeing it for themselves and getting all the facts are being shown for the idiots they truly are, many continuing to live in denial of the facts.

Sean Hannity is perhaps the best example, as last night he interviewed someone who saw the movie at its premiere at Sundance. I forget the lady's name, but I believe she is a conservative District Attorney and a child advocate for 30 years, so Hannity was a bit surprised when she revealed that all the negative claims about Dakota's infamous rape scene simply aren't true. According to her, all we see is Dakota from her shoulders on up and the guy's arm. There is no touching, and the rape is actually achieved through editing tricks, and not on the set as some have claimed. She explained that it occurs more in the viewer's mind than in the movie.

But Hannity was not satisfied, claiming that what she saw was a "sanitized" version, and that he wanted to see everything that was left on the cutting room floor. Um, right, Sean. You haven't see the movie, you weren't involved in the editing process, you weren't involved in the production whatsoever, yet you somehow know what "really" went on. What a jackass.

 
At 9:33 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I sure wouldn't let my daughter do that. Talk about exposure to things at a young age...at her age I would think any kind ove sexual content would be upsetting. And rape is upsetting sexual content at any age!!

 
At 4:19 PM, Blogger Michelle said...

I haven't heard anything about this movie. 12 does seem like such a young age to portray a character going through something so awful like that. I guess it really depends on your own child though and whether you think they are mature enough to handle that type of role and how it might affect them. I would be leery about letting my 12-yr old, but hopefully her parents really talked to her about this role and all that went along with it.

 
At 7:02 PM, Anonymous Gina said...

Until now, I haven't heard anything about this film. Just reading your post and the comments, I would have to say no. I have a teenage son and a elementary age daughter. I think its the job of parents to guard their children's hearts and minds. Eventually the world will seep in but its our job to protect them as long as we can. This is one of the reasons why I homeschool.

 
At 7:33 PM, Anonymous chelle said...

I do not think I would put my child in acting. That being said this is not this young actor's first movie and therefore she has some experience with "pretend" and "reality". Acting is a job for her, like going to school is for other children. I am not convinced that it is the root of evil. I am not sure as a pregnant mother I would go see the movie, however I would not want the movie to be censored out either.

I am torn. Very interesting topic!

 
At 10:56 PM, Blogger Tammy and Parker said...

I don't care if this scene was created with the smoke and mirrors of editing. One's mind is filling in the blanks. What exactly is the difference of seeing it in your mind or seeing it on the screen? A 12 year old girl is still a major part of the action here.

What kind of thoughts and feelings did Miss Flanning have to dig into in order to protray this experience?

Now I'm waiting for those who will say that if a 12 year old is old enough to portray a rape victim, then a 12 year old should be old enough to watch too.


I would think that Miss Flanning's intellect is most likely on a much more mature level than the average 12 year old. But that in itself one thing that as parents we worry so much about: children growing up too fast and getting into situations that they are not emotionally ready to handle.

Word on the street here in Utah is that Sundance is way dark this year.

 
At 10:19 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I think this little gal is a victim of neglect like so many TV and movie stars. I think of Drew Barrymore's years of alcohol and drugs, he Olson girls bout with anorexia, and there are so many more. A few years ago their was a special on TV about child stars and the things they had gone through. What is came down to was neglect by the parents. They live off of their children's money, plain and simple.

I think child labor laws in the movie and TV industry are very lax but many movies are also filmed out of the country where there are no laws at all.

Fanning is only 12 years old. The child is most likely just entering puberty. She is being manipulated and used. It is disgusting. And sadly she is not the first.

Also at the Sundance Film festival was a documentary on bestiality (Zoo). I haven't heard much about that but I mean just how perverted are people?

 
At 10:44 PM, Blogger Nesting For Natalie said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home





Name: Overwhelmed

My complete profile

It wasn't supposed to work this way...Parts 1 through 10

(the story of the private, domestic adoption of our son)


(Part 1)
(Part 2)
(Part 3)
(Part 4)
(Part 5)
(Part 6)
(Part 7)
(Part 8)
(Part 9)
(Part 10- Adoption Finalization)

Fostering isn't for the faint of heart!

(our journey to adopt again through foster-to-adopt, the good, the bad, & everything in between)


Adoption #2- considering the State
More Adoption #2 thoughts
Adoption #2- Back to considering the State
Adoption #2- The Paperwork (Round 1)
Adoption #2- The Paperwork (Round 2)
Family Foster Home Licensing Prep Checklist
Adoption #2- Long overdue update
PS-MAPP class homework assignment
Our preliminary home inspection went well!
Adoption #2: Licensing update
Adoption #2- Foster Facts
Adoption #2: I love it when things go my way!
Adoption #2- The home inspection
Adoption #2- We failed our home inspection!
Adoption #2- We passed the follow-up home inspection!
Adoption #2- Still waiting
Adoption #2- We're getting closer
Adoption #2- An update & a lead
Adoption #2- The lead that didn't pan out.
Adoption #2- We're licensed!
Adoption #2- We have a tiny baby here!
Adoption #2- Update on this precious little girl.
Adoption #2- Quick update on Baby Bug
Adoption #2- Baby Bug is staying longer!
Adoption #2- Baby Bug is growing!
Adoption #2- Overdue update on Baby Bug
Adoption #2- The latest on Baby Bug
Adoption #2- Shopping spree for Baby Bug
Being a Foster Parent Does Not Make Me A Saint
Adoption #2- Another Placement Call!
Adoption #2- Placement Meeting- UPDATED!
Adoption #2- We have Boo at our home!
Adoption #2- Meeting Boo
Adoption #2- I'm angry on Boo's behalf!
Adoption #2- A Birthday Party for Boo
Adjusting to three 3 and under!
Stressful moments in fostering.
Adoption #2- Update on our foster daughters
CPS Workers Jerking Our Chain!
It's getting much worse!
Fostering: Update on Baby Bug
Fostering: Update on Boo
The effects of fostering on Snuggle Bug
The time is drawing near to let go of Baby Bug.
Good conversation with Baby Bug's dad.
Boo has a Permanency hearing coming soon!
My heart is breaking!
Bittersweet news about Baby Bug.
Next Friday is going to be tough.
Packing up Baby Bug's belongings
It's done- Baby Bug is gone.
Working on finding peace, one day at a time.
Referral to the Early Intervention Program
Baby Bug update
Home Inspection for re-licensing
Parole granted for Boo's bio mom
Baby Bug is turning 1 year old soon.
Day 2 of Boo's permanency hearing
A prayer answered today!
Attending Baby Bug's 1st birthday party
Foster news
Good news for Boo's case
Boo's bio family visits
Termination Trial date set!
A new caseworker for Boo
I've been asked to testify in court.
Court hearing for "John Doe"
Contested termination trial begins tomorrow afternoon
Boo's adoption has been finalized!

Alamogordo, here I come!
Favorite Ingredients Friday (Garlic Linguine)
Relationship-Building Activities for You and Your ...
WFMW (calendar labels)
For Kelli
Royal Potty review
Favorite Ingredients Friday (Pizza Bake)
WFMW (Strawberry Spinach Salad)
Listening to your body
Keeping children fit and active
























Add to Technorati Favorites Blog Flux Directory Google PageRank 
Checker Tool



Parenting Blogs - Blog Top Sites

Top Parents blogs

Subscribe to Overwhelmed With Joy!

Add to My AOL

Add to netvibes

Powered by FeedBurner

Subscribe with Bloglines Add to Google


Powered By: